Current Conditions
69°F - SUNNY
Lippiatt ruled insane in slaying of 2 sons
Lancaster New Era
Dec 10, 2007 12:20 EST
LANCASTER
By JANET KELLEY, CINDY STAUFFER and TOM MURSE

The complete text of this article is no longer available online.

Recent Posts
Showing 5 most recent comments out of 27 total TalkBack comments about this article
View full comments | Comment on this article
QUOTE(justplainjoe @ Dec 11 2007, 11:38 AM)


progressive, compassionate societies do not execute the mentally ill or children


Which is exactly why America is in the sad condition it is. Kids kill with no retribution, adults kill with little retribution, there's no reason not to kill when nothing happens to you.
Steal something, nothing happens, what reason would you have to stop? Throw acid onto vehicles causing thousands of dollars in damage and what happens to you? NOTHING.

grieker
QUOTE(Scubabike420 @ Dec 11 2007, 10:35 AM)

And this is exactly the part that needs more attention. It is very likely that Mrs. Lippiatt was taking psychotropic medication prior to this crime. Some will argue that her crime is proof that she needed these medications, but could it be that these medications created the mental state that allowed her to committe this unthinkable crime? Are we to believe that psychotropic drugs only have a positive impact on a person's mental health without introducing or amplifying negative emotions and thoughts? These medications are used because of their impact on mental processes. Impacts that many claim continue in the form of extreme withdraw for months. The typical approach of running patients through several medications until the "right combination" is obtained has these people living in an almost unreal world of medication side effects and withdraw symptoms.

The connection between this type of crime and medications deserve more attention.


If Mrs. Lippiatt was indeed taking psychotropic medication prior to the crime, I'd agree with your points, Scuba, and support investigation into a possible relationship.

BeingReal
QUOTE

Find me a woman who died of prostate cancer and I'll find you a man who murdered because he had postpartum psychosis.


Bad analogy. Women don't have prostates, but both men and women have brains.

QUOTE

Men and women ARE different. I would be willing to bet that you would be sympathetic to a man who was a soldier in Iraq, went through several close calls with IEDs and had to clean up slaughtered innocents, and then returned to the US and was put in a long waiting line at the VA for severe psychological problems that were triggered by his time in Iraq... who then went on to harming others.


Sure, men and women are different, but only when it's convenient to note the difference. The issue isn't whether I would be sympathetic to such a man, but whether the law would be, and I think we can agree that it wouldn't. The root of the problem is that when a woman sends her children into a lake strapped into a baby seat in a car, or drowns her 5 kids in a bathtub, or sticks a baby in a microwave oven, there's always an acronym for it and she's considered the victim and deserves all our sympathy when she hits the talk show circuit. When a man does it, he's a ruthless monster who deserves a slow, painful death.

There are plenty of other double standards when it comes to accountability. Take for instance alcohol and sex. If the woman is drunk and she later regrets the act, it's considered rape. If the man is drunk as well, he doesn't get a free pass. The law won't hold a woman accountable for giving the green light while she's intoxicated, but it will hold the man accountable for acting on the green light, despite the fact that he's drunk as well. Hell, if he regrets the act, do you suppose he can claim she took advantage of him and charge the woman with rape? Yes, it sounds ridiculous when you turn the tables.
Subsonix
There was no acronym in the Susan Smith case. She's in jail for as long as the law allows.
LicenseForMayhem
QUOTE
There was no acronym in the Susan Smith case. She's in jail for as long as the law allows.


OK good, but the Andrea Yates thing...
Subsonix
Top Ads