Current Conditions
65°F - CLOUDY
'Super supplement' planned for error-filled L-S yearbook
Intelligencer Journal
Published: Jun 18, 2008
00:52 EST
Lampeter
By KIM O’BRIEN, Staff

Lampeter-Strasburg High School students were upset about pages in their yearbook that contained typogr...(more)
 
1 of 1
Lampeter-Strasburg students upset over the quality of their yearbooks have been promised a "super supplement" to the error-laden book.

Students received letters, dated June 12, from principal Carroll Staub stating that a supplement to the yearbook will be published containing corrected pages, color photos and spring sports and club pages usually excluded because of publication deadlines.

The decision was made at a meeting held in early June between Staub, superintendent Robert Frick, a yearbook adviser and a representative of yearbook publishing company Herff Jones.

The original yearbook contains typographical errors, misidentified photos and photos of students from other school districts. Also, students were upset that senior Ryan Weitzel's photo was excluded from the book. Weitzel died in April after a five-year battle with malignant melanoma.

The issue was addressed at Monday night's school board meeting.

"Dr. Frick made a comment to the fact that the supplement was going to be done as an extended, larger-than-normal version to accommodate some of the things that were missed," James Byrnes, school board president, said. "They will address the things that were incorrect and try to make good."

Students paid $55 for the 320-page, hardcover books that were published by Herff Jones of Indiana.

Those who purchased copies will receive the "super supplement" free of charge. Graduates' copies will be mailed to their homes. Underclassmen can pick up the supplement at the high school office when it is available in early August.

"I appreciate that they're trying to improve it. It's better than before," Leslie Buch, a 2008 graduate, said. Buch tagged more than 150 errors in the book and showed them to Staub.

"It shows that they care. Before, it seemed like nobody was going to do anything," Buch said.

The letter states that the supplement will "accomplish three things: highlight the inspiration provided this year by Ryan 'Whitey' Weitzel, correct as many of the glaring errors/mistakes as possible, and attempt to restore faith and pride in this publication."

Those dissatisfied with the administration's solution can return yearbooks to the high school's main office by July 15 for a full refund.

"Anybody who was upset with the book had the opportunity to get their money back at the outset," Byrnes said.

"This is the the kind of thing I would assume our administration can handle, and it seems like they are taking the right steps to fix it," he said.

E-mail: kobrien@lnpnews.com


Recent Posts
Showing 5 most recent comments out of 9 total TalkBack comments about this article
View full comments | Comment on this article
QUOTE(Yota98 @ Jun 18 2008, 11:51 AM)
Judging by what was decided, I'd say the errors came from the school. Anyone else still think it was the publishing companies fault??


Both are probably at fault to a degree. Nothing L-S did would have added photos of kids from other schools.
LicenseForMayhem
LS would have had to approve the final copy before print. I think that, in the end, this was the school districts fault. The printer could make the mistakes but the school district is acting as if they have some responsibility leading me to believe they approved incorrect copy and pictures.

If it was the printers mistake, believe me, they could have been forced to provide new year books. The fact that this isn't happening says LS to me.
Solancoforever
QUOTE(Solancoforever @ Jun 18 2008, 11:41 PM)
LS would have had to approve the final copy before print. I think that, in the end, this was the school districts fault. The printer could make the mistakes but the school district is acting as if they have some responsibility leading me to believe they approved incorrect copy and pictures.

If it was the printers mistake, believe me, they could have been forced to provide new year books. The fact that this isn't happening says LS to me.


If there are whole sections of another school's stuff in there, I can't see how that would happen without the printer being at fault. After working in printing and advertising, I can tell you that almost anything can be screwed up at the printer. All you need is some bad prepress file management, and...

But, then again, I guess almost anything's possible on the school's end if things were rushed through without checking them well. That's one expensive and important book not to check, though....

Unless things have changed, L-S always did a regular supplement, distributed in the fall, that covered the prom, graduation, spring sports, and would probably include a tribute to a senior who died after the original book went to press.
LicenseForMayhem
QUOTE(LicenseForMayhem @ Jun 18 2008, 11:58 PM)

Unless things have changed, L-S always did a regular supplement, distributed in the fall, that covered the prom, graduation, spring sports, and would probably include a tribute to a senior who died after the original book went to press.


Don't know when they started or stopped that, but there was no such thing when I attended LSHS in 1993-1994, and I stayed friends with several people who never recieved such a thing in the subsequent three years as far s I know.
fuego
I discussed this with my brother, who has worked in publishing for 15+ years. The pics of the kids from other schools are the fault of the publisher-they probably got pages mixed up while printing multiple schools at once. But text errors, mislabled pics, etc., fall on the school. The printers don't read the things they're printing and edit them, they print what they are given. ANd usually before the final product is printed, a proof is sent to the client for approval. SO, as far as textual errors, someone at LS dropped the ball and didnt edit and proofread their copy.
mrsuwe1
Top Ads