Current Conditions
36°F - SUNNY
Ex-coroner files illness claim
Kirchner says work in morgue made him sick
Intelligencer Journal
Published: Aug 06, 2008
01:12 EST
Lancaster
By BRETT HAMBRIGHT, Staff

Gary Kirchner
 
1 of 1
Former Coroner G. Gary Kirchner has filed a workers' compensation claim for more than $500,000 against Lancaster County, alleging he developed a debilitating bacterial infection while working last year in the county morgue.

Kirchner, who served as the county's coroner from 2004 to 2007, has been hospitalized since Dec. 29, 2007. Doctors diagnosed his illness as septicemia, or bacteria in the blood. It's also called "blood poisoning."

The infection has hampered the former surgeon's mobility, caused severe weight loss and diminished his vision. Kirchner said Tuesday one doctor diagnosed him as legally blind.

He uses a wheelchair and was unable to attend a Tuesday hearing about his claim.

Attorney Harvey Miller is representing Kirchner. Paul Clouser is representing the county.

Kirchner's petition alleges he was infected while performing an autopsy in December in the basement of Conestoga View nursing home, where the morgue is located. Kirchner said his left pinkie finger was cut on a contaminated stainless steel autopsy table.

Kirchner is asking for reimbursement of more than $500,000 in medical costs accumulated during the seven months he has spent under 24-hour care. He said he has been seen by 23 specialists and takes more than 20 pills a day to treat the "devastating" infection.

Medicare covers the bulk of his medical bills, Kirchner said.

The county is rebutting Kirchner's claim on two grounds: the Pennsylvania Workers' Compensation Act doesn't cover elected officials, and there is no proof Kirchner was infected while on the job.

"We are aware of no medical evidence suggesting a link between Dr. Kirchner's illness and his activities as coroner," Clouser said Tuesday in a statement.

Miller told Judge Michael R. Hetrick there are certain subsections of the Workers Compensation Act that apply to Kirchner.

Hetrick told both attorneys Tuesday that a hearing on the claim will be held in late September.

Kirchner is expected to testify. Sue Finefrock, who has worked as office manager for two ex-coroners — including Kirchner — and the current coroner, is expected to testify for the county.

Kirchner said his petition is unusual because workers' compensation claims usually involve laborers.

"Most worker's compensation (claimants) don't wear suits to work," Kirchner said.

He said the money he is seeking from the county will continue to increase because he is hospitalized indefinitely at Manor Health Care Services on Abbeyville Road.

"The county stands to lose a lot of money because the county had no insurance for this type of incident," Kirchner said.

Kirchner said doctors have not given him a timetable for when he will be able to return to his East Lampeter Township home.

"If I knew where the end point is, I would feel much better," he said.

E-mail: bhambright@lnpnews.com


Recent Posts
Showing 5 most recent comments out of 26 total TalkBack comments about this article
View full comments | Comment on this article
maybe he's just a necrophiliac , should have worn his raincoat .

caitlinndad
Not to sound heartless, but as a County taxpayer, he's suing for my money. So my first thought was this: if he was the coroner, and he caught the infection from a sharp, dirty morgue table, wasn't the condition of the table his responsibility? How can he sue the County for the conditions of a facility that was under his control? If it's his insurance company suing the County, couldn't the County then sue him?

I'm sure I'm wrong, and somebody will tell me why.

greidel
QUOTE(lanzate @ Aug 5 2008, 10:12 PM)

Wow, that is really sad. Can this guy be any more unlucky. $500,000 workman's comp!? I thought workman's comp only paid for time off work and the medical expenses just went through your regular insurance, or maybe it is his insurance that is suing the county to recover some of their obligation. someone else will have to explain this one, i've never had to file a workman's comp claim.

If a work comp claim is justified, the workers comp insurance pays all the bills, not just your pay while off work.

QUOTE(greidel @ Aug 6 2008, 11:08 AM)

Not to sound heartless, but as a County taxpayer, he's suing for my money. So my first thought was this: if he was the coroner, and he caught the infection from a sharp, dirty morgue table, wasn't the condition of the table his responsibility? How can he sue the County for the conditions of a facility that was under his control? If it's his insurance company suing the County, couldn't the County then sue him?

I'm sure I'm wrong, and somebody will tell me why.


It doesn't matter who was "at fault" the workers comp insurance must pay the bills if the injury occured at work; however, since Dr. Kirchner was an elected official, he was not covered by worker's comp insurance. His attorney says there are subsections that do cover him so I guess we shall see after the hearing.
Hope
QUOTE(Hope @ Aug 6 2008, 11:19 AM)

If a work comp claim is justified, the workers comp insurance pays all the bills, not just your pay while off work.
It doesn't matter who was "at fault" the workers comp insurance must pay the bills if the injury occured at work; however, since Dr. Kirchner was an elected official, he was not covered by worker's comp insurance. His attorney says there are subsections that do cover him so I guess we shall see after the hearing.


And as this goes to court, depending on how tenacious both sides are, and how far the court allows this to progress, just the evidence stuff is going to be costly. How does either side determine WHERE the initial injury took place? Did I read that he did NOT file a notice about the injury taking place at work at the time that it happened? Now it is just going to be his word. And, I have to say, with wounds and serious infection, it can be hard to determine WHICH WOUND and WHEN that wound happened. There is DNA testing of bacteria -- that is what led the FBI to the anthrax lab and scientists -- but that means they would have to find that same bacteria present IN THE MORGUE -- STILL ON SURFACES -- and after all this time, and repeated normal day to day cleaning procedures, that might be unlikely.
AngelFace
This "idiot" doesn't have to resort to calling names. I only call it like I see it. So he loses the election and then gets sick. Amazing stroke of "unfortunate events" don't you think? Well, besides for the rest of the previous year that he graced the news.
hibshjr
Top Ads