Current Conditions
30°F - CLOUDY
Amish school shootings: 2 years later
Lancaster New Era
Published: Oct 01, 2008
09:17 EST
Lancaster
By JACK BRUBAKER, Staff Writer
Two years have passed since a gunman entered an Amish school in Nickel Mines, dismissed the teacher and all the boys and shot 10 girls, killing five,  before killing himself.
An Amish buggy travels in the fog this morning along Mine Road near the one-room New Hope School, whic...(more)
 
1 of 1

The brutal massacre of innocent children stunned the community and shocked the world.

Even now, some residents say, it seems as if such horror could not have occurred in this quiet crossroads town surrounded by farms in Bart Township.

"Passing the site almost daily," notes an Amish resident of Nickel Mines, "it seems at times almost like a dream. I can't believe it happened."

The Amish community has done what it could to erase the worst memories of Oct. 2, 2006 — two years ago Thursday.

The old school is gone, replaced by New Hope School in the spring of 2007. The affected families work hard at forgiving the gunman, protecting their children and looking to the future.

But the school's students remain bound by an unforgettable nightmare.

"It's going to take a whole generation of kids to grow up and not remember that day," says a health care worker who is close to the school families. "Even now you say '10/2' and everyone knows what you're talking about."

The students lost an ally when the teacher who comforted them  after Oct. 2 left this year to teach Amish vocational school. A new teacher has taken her place.
Related Topics

Several of the children who were in the school that day have graduated to vocational school or farm work. New scholars have taken their desks.

School will be closed Thursday in recognition of what happened two years ago. Parents of school children will gather in the evening.

One of their primary topics of conversation, as with any group of parents, will be their children.

On the sunny Monday morning that Charles Carl Roberts IV, of nearby Georgetown, brought sudden death to Nickel Mines, he also brought physical and psychological distress that at first threatened to overwhelm the little crossroads community.

Roberts killed five of the girls outright.

The five girls Roberts wounded remain hurt in various ways.

He shot two girls in the head.

Rosanna King, now 8, was the worst hurt. Doctors thought she would die. Many in the community view her survival as a miracle.

Herman Bontrager, an Akron businessman who speaks for the Nickel Mines Amish, says Rosanna "is going to a school for children in her physical and cognitive condition, but she's not able to do anything for herself."

Sarah Ann Stoltzfus, now 10, the other girl with a head injury, has progressed well beyond doctors' expectations.

Though she still has vision problems, she is a "straight-A student, spunky and full of it," according to the health care worker.

Barbie Fisher, Rachel Ann Stoltzfus and Esther King, the other three wounded girls, are still recuperating. Each has had additional surgery and therapy.

The Nickel Mines Accountability Committee continues to allocate, as needed, more than $4 million in donated funds for medical procedures and counseling for the surviving children.

Many of the 15 boys Roberts ordered out of the classroom feel responsible for leaving their friends behind. Some have suffered profound psychological pain.

"In the long term, some of the boys have had serious medical issues," says the health care worker. "Other boys, who weren't even in the school but live in the neighborhood, have had trouble."

Acknowledges the parent of a school child, "Some of the boys are emotional. I don't know that the pain will ever go completely away. These children will carry scars for a lifetime."

But life does go on.

In the past two years, all of the families who lost girls to the gunman on Oct. 2 have welcomed new babies into the world.

Two new families moved into the school district this year, adding new girls to a school that is still out of balance (20 boys, eight girls) because Roberts shot only girls.

And there is a constant sign to the community that something larger was at work in the Nickel Mines tragedy.

"Rosanna is our reminder," says the school parent. "I feel God spared her life for a reason. She reminds us that the Lord was still in control on that day."

The parents of New Hope School, when they gather Thursday evening, will discuss something besides their children.

They were at ground zero when the unbelievable occurred. They constantly support each other as unexpected aftershocks hit home.

"The journey is a long one — to work on how to deal with a loss like this and the ongoing pain," says Bontrager. "It means working on forgiveness over and over, among other things."


Staff writer Jack Brubaker can be reached at jbrubaker@LNPnews.com or 291-8781.

Recent Posts
Showing 5 most recent comments out of 35 total TalkBack comments about this article
View full comments | Comment on this article
QUOTE (Eric_R @ Oct 1 2008, 01:08 PM)
SteelerFanInPA: that is about the most insensative item I've ever read here. Are you annoyed at the topic? Are you disgusted by what happened? I hope you are annoyed and disguested...to the point that you'll make a difference, get involved, or do something to insure that this doesn't happen to someone you care about. The open-trusting that the Amish community has was totally shattered that day. Think about your normal routine this morning (i.e. leaving your spouse to go work, have breakfast with your kids or putting them on the bus for school). Now, imagine that person dead - killed in horrific tragedy. Now, add that your neighbor is going through the same tragedy....add another....add another....add another. The article isn't to revive the past, its to heal those who haven't been able to move on. Once your read the headline, you have the option of moving to the next news artice. I truly don't see the reason or purpose in your sardonic question.


As a neighbor of close proximity where this happened I agree w/Steelerfan. Frankly, I think all the attention this has brought and the "anniversaries" /book signings/money " that has been generated via the Amish school shootings vehicle is great fodder for a copycat killer.

Its time to move on. We don't have to forget but we don't have to be reminded about it either every year. That was one screwed up day in our little town and out of RESPECT to the people personally involved, many who have no need to be reminded of this yearly can we not just shut up about it already?

QUOTE (taxlady @ Oct 1 2008, 10:55 PM)
I noticed that a meat market and restaurant recently opened directly across from the the Bart Fire Company (one of the 1st responders). I hope they do well.

and past the Bullfrog on that strip of land they are planning 'cluster housing'. :-< Im dismayed at the amt of traffic that is gonna produce. The climate/charm of our little town is changing. Im not real happy w/the 'development'. I see development of many homes too...the homes on Eden Road where I saw wild deer sometimes as I drove by saddens me.

Before long Lancaster will look like Chester County if we don't watch it.

QUOTE (lanzate @ Oct 1 2008, 11:45 PM)
The people who object to LNP printing this article are speaking about themselves not the Amish community. The Amish welcome this story to be told. I have spent a lot of time with the Amish. My job gets me in contact with them almost ever day and some who are even close to this tragedy. They are frequently misunderstood. Stick a camera in their face with a microphone and yes they will protest but they still welcome their story to be told.

In every Amish house you will find 2 books written in German. One is the Bible, the other is the Martyrs Mirror. This is a book that details their long persecution at the hands of Protestants and Catholics in Europe before the Quaker, William Penn invited them to settle here.

Jesus was descried as a "man of sorrows, familiar with suffering". The Amish are happy people and I have met more then I can count with a real twinkle in their eye but they also live closer to the reality of sadness than any people group I have ever met.


Not the Amish I know. On the 'retelling of the story' media wise I've heard many comment that they wish 'they' would stop dredging it up. Why do you think signs were erected in our town telling the media to leave them alone and let them grieve in peace?
spaylady
QUOTE (spaylady @ Oct 3 2008, 09:01 AM)
As a neighbor of close proximity where this happened I agree w/Steelerfan. Frankly, I think all the attention this has brought and the "anniversaries" /book signings/money " that has been generated via the Amish school shootings vehicle is great fodder for a copycat killer.

Its time to move on. We don't have to forget but we don't have to be reminded about it either every year. That was one screwed up day in our little town and out of RESPECT to the people personally involved, many who have no need to be reminded of this yearly can we not just shut up about it already?

Do you understand the absudity of calling one annual newspaper article "all this attention"?? The headline is clear enough...if the subject doesn't personally interest you, skip it. That is your right to passover something that is not worthy of your time. You change the TV station or radio channel when something isn't to your favor - do the same with the newspaper.
I'm sure you have pride in your little town. This article should invoke some sence OF COMMUNITY within you. In two years, what have you done - small or large - to help your little town not have a "copycat" incident?? Copycat crimes are not born from quiet news articles. They are born from sensationalism of crime - the gore, the infamity.
The Independant Film Channel (IFC) recent showed a moive called "Elephant". The movie is about two kids who copycat the Columbine High School massacre. The characters is very belivable; the detail of the incident is good. I'm 1,000 times more scared that kids will see this movie and execute the plan over anyone reading this news article and becoming a "copycat". I'd ask that you preview the movie and then come back to compare this article versus the movie.
Eric_R
QUOTE (Eric_R @ Oct 3 2008, 12:09 PM)
Do you understand the absudity of calling one annual newspaper article "all this attention"?? The headline is clear enough...if the subject doesn't personally interest you, skip it. That is your right to passover something that is not worthy of your time. You change the TV station or radio channel when something isn't to your favor - do the same with the newspaper.
I'm sure you have pride in your little town. This article should invoke some sence OF COMMUNITY within you. In two years, what have you done - small or large - to help your little town not have a "copycat" incident?? Copycat crimes are not born from quiet news articles. They are born from sensationalism of crime - the gore, the infamity.
The Independant Film Channel (IFC) recent showed a moive called "Elephant". The movie is about two kids who copycat the Columbine High School massacre. The characters is very belivable; the detail of the incident is good. I'm 1,000 times more scared that kids will see this movie and execute the plan over anyone reading this news article and becoming a "copycat". I'd ask that you preview the movie and then come back to compare this article versus the movie.


How can you prevent some crazy person from doing something like this anyway? I think you know what I was getting at. Its not just the Nickel Mines Tragedy...its anything violent that goes down anywhere. Look at all the attention that is generated.

And the 'little newspaper article ' was on the front page. How do you think this makes the wife of the shooter feel every time she sees it? No one knew who 'Charles Roberts' was til he committed this crime. And what is sad...is I was his neighbor and I didnt know his name til AFTER he did this.
Oh well....that said, see you in this forum when they report it again next yr. Year after year the magnitude of the hoopla will probably die down. And there will be more screwed up things to report. (going on in our world.)

QUOTE (spaylady @ Oct 3 2008, 04:21 PM)
How can you prevent some crazy person from doing something like this anyway? I think you know what I was getting at. Its not just the Nickel Mines Tragedy...its anything violent that goes down anywhere. Look at all the attention that is generated.

And the 'little newspaper article ' was on the front page. How do you think this makes the wife of the shooter feel every time she sees it? No one knew who 'Charles Roberts' was til he committed this crime. And what is sad...is I was his neighbor and I didnt know his name til AFTER he did this.
Oh well....that said, see you in this forum when they report it again next yr. Year after year the magnitude of the hoopla will probably die down. And there will be more screwed up things to report. (going on in our world.)
spaylady
QUOTE (groundpounder @ Oct 2 2008, 11:43 AM)
No, watcher, RR is not a good one to debate with because he knows nothing about what is going on in the law enforcement community, today....
.... They were trying to talk to him. RR wants them to go right in.

There's a time to wait, and there's a time to act. Patrol, or SWAT must consider anyone who has entered a school with a gun as a weapon of mass destruction, regardless of the perceived dangers of an immediate rescue to innocents trapped inside. The dangers of waiting are far greater than allowing the invader time to set up and the begin the inevitable killing. Waiting for the gunfire to begin before allowing aggressive action against an armed threat inside a school is foolish, and needs to be reevaluted with a dose of common sense.

Not every police department shares GP's standardized (and popular) "surround, gather information and try to talk" tactics, as shown by this recent citizen rescue in Salt Lake City:
QUOTE
"The operation is similar to what officers involved in the Trolley Square tragedy did, she said. Rather than set up a containment around the business, police broke in the door and entered."
ReaganRepublican
QUOTE (starviego @ Oct 2 2008, 07:27 PM)
Solanco,

Sorry to hear about your PTSD. I can only imagine how horrible such an event can be. But this is one of those crimes that will be discussed forever, because it cannot be considered closed until a real motive can be adduced.

Famous FBI profiler John Douglas on "motiveless crimes": "....there is, in fact, no such thing. Every crime has a motive." -- From his book "the Anatomy of Motive"


He's dead get over it. You can analyze all you want but the only person who could actually tell you is dead.
Solancoforever
Top Ads