It's not uncommon for folks in the more "rural" areas to run with more than one company. And neighboring companies are brought in to fight the fires. My bet is on a firefighter.

My bet is on an Amish hate

My bet is on a teenager who went off to college (or the military) and has returned after 4 years

Or maybe someone who was in prison.

Biker gangs tied to slaying?Law enforcement probing links among murder victim, his friend who witnessed the killing, and the Pagans. "According to federal indictments in the case, the Pagans obtained drugs and sold them to Amish people for distribution in Lancaster County at hoedowns — traditional gatherings for Amish and other teens and young adults."
Being relatively new to this area I had no idea...
Settling old scores???