QUOTE (citydweller @ Jun 1 2009, 08:56 PM)
edited, due to length......
But, if "English" farmers could make their kids run heavy equipment and take them out of school after 8th grade and work them full-time, don't you think some of them would?
Well, there's your Amish world. Less regulated, largely untaxed, more prone (in the press anyway) to "home incidents" than what we expect to see in our "English" world. Also more attuned to community pressure, to the point of potentially being driven out and expelled. Can't legally do that in our world, and I got 50 phone book covers full 'o lawyers that say so.
Citydweller, good post except you do have some misconceptions.
It is legal for ALL people, not just the Amish, to remove their kids from school at a certain age (I am not sure if it is age 15 or 16).
The only tax some Amish do not pay are Social Security taxes, but than those who do not pay, do not collect either. Other than that the Amish pay ALL the same taxes, that the English do. They help pay, but don't accept, welfare, food stamps, fuel assistance, reduced housing, free school lunches, grants, clothing allowances, earned income credit, etc. They pay dearly for the Engish's kid’s education, but the English don’t pay for their kid’s education.
The argument is that they don't pay the taxes at the fuel pump. However many of them hire drivers to take them places. And trust me, the Amish do alot of traveling to the Amish settlements in other states. They pay those drivers dearly. So indirectly they do pay the taxes at the pump.