Current Conditions
55°F - P/SUNNY
School bus drivers unionize
Intelligencer Journal
Jun 13, 2009 00:44 EST
By BRIAN WALLACE, Staff Writer

Shane Stewart has been driving a school bus for 14 years and said he loves shuttling students to and from Lancaster County Career & Technology Center schools each day.

What he said he doesn't love is his pay — $13.30 an hour — and benefits, including a health care plan Stewart said isn't worth what employees pay each month for coverage.

Stewart said he also wants "more fairness" in how his employer, First Student, awards routes to drivers and pays them for field trips.

Because of these and other issues, Stewart joined 67 other First Student drivers June 3 who voted to join the Teamsters Union.

The 68-40 vote in favor of representation by Teamsters Local 771 marks the second time in three months Lancaster County school bus drivers have unionized.

First Student drivers in Hempfield School District voted March 11 to join an affiliate of the state teachers union, becoming the first school bus drivers in Lancaster County to unionize, according to union officials.

And union reps say they expect more drivers to follow suit in the next year.

Whether the upcoming union contracts increase the cost of transportation services for school districts — and, ultimately, taxpayers — remains to be seen.

But the unions are clearly bucking for higher wages for their members.

"Some of these people are making only $10 to $12 an hour, which is hard to believe when you consider they're transporting kids and having to accept that liability," Mike Green, president of Local 771, said.

"They're completely underpaid. I have warehouse workers who are making more than that."

The Teamsters contract will cover more than 100 drivers and bus aides for the CTC, Elizabethtown Area and Donegal school districts, Lancaster-Lebanon Intermediate Unit 13 and several private schools, including Lancaster Catholic High School and St. Leo's Catholic School.

Union membership will likely give the drivers and aides the right to strike.

First Student, which provides busing services under contract to hundreds of school districts across the country, has a "hands-off" approach to unionization, spokeswoman Nicol Jones said.

"We have a relatively unique policy which allows for our employees to decide for themselves whether or not they want to be in a union," she said.

"We don't pursue union membership for drivers, but we have no conflict with it."

About half of First Student's drivers are unionized, and that number has increased modestly in recent years, Jones said.

Stewart said he is hoping a union contract results in higher pay and improved working conditions for him and his colleagues.

"As it is now, garbage truck drivers get paid more than school bus drivers," he said. "The nation's future is worth less than garbage, and that's not right."

Stewart said he also wants First Student to pay drivers their regular salary for field trips, instead of the flat rate of $10.80 an hour they now pay.

He said he also wants more transparency in how First Union awards routes to drivers and more support from the company.

For example, drivers are expected to clean out their vehicles every day, but the company doesn't provide brooms and limits the number of paper towels drivers may have, Stewart said.

Green said the push to unionize drivers here is part of a national Teamsters campaign, Drive Up Standards, that has been targeting private school bus and transit workers since 2006.

Last year, First Student bus drivers in Harrisburg School District joined the Teamsters.

Those drivers authorized a strike two weeks ago when they couldn't reach an agreement with First Student on a contract, but a compromise was reached, and the strike was averted.

No details on the contract were available.

Green said Teamsters representatives have spoken with drivers for other school bus companies in Lancaster County who are closely monitoring how the unionized drivers fare in their new contracts.

"Once they see that, we expect other bus drivers to want to get in touch about becoming a Teamster," he said. "We anticipate a lot more drivers getting in touch with us."

Jones said there isn't necessarily a direct correlation between higher wages for drivers and higher contract costs for schools.

"The company will negotiate with the union just as it has with individual drivers," she said. "Regardless of who we're negotiating with, it's going to be a competitive rate."

Higher pay for drivers "might impact us indirectly," Donegal superintendent Shelly Riedel said. She declined to comment further, saying she was not familiar enough with the First Student contract.

Troy Portser, a spokesman for Elizabethtown Area School District, said it would be premature to comment on the potential impact of driver wage increases on the district's transportation contract.

E-town is in the final year of a five-year contract with First Student worth about $1.5 million a year.

"The drivers are employed by First Student, so the major impact would be on them," he said.

Once the union negotiates a contract for the drivers, they will begin paying monthly union dues equivalent to 2 or 2½ times their hourly pay rate.

Stewart will pay $33.25 a month based on his current rate, or about $400 a year — an expense he's more than willing to incur for union representation.

"For having the backing that we need and having a voice and getting respect, that's totally worth it," he said.

E-mail: bwallace@lnpnews.com


Recent Posts
Showing 5 most recent comments out of 38 total TalkBack comments about this article
View full comments | Comment on this article
QUOTE (Beth @ Jun 15 2009, 11:23 AM)
Sorry, about that! I'll try to do better if and when there's a next time! I wasn't sure at the time if it was only going to be just Kate and I. As it turned out Strobe, Jrmwarfare, Mac n friend, Kate and myself were there. I'm certain you would have livened the conversation, which was already a riot!!

BTW Chance, you would have had a lot of fun!! Poor Strobe was a Rose among the thorns!!, or onion in a Petunia patch, I'm not quite sure.

If there's a next time? Sounds as if you guys got "ugly"? lol

Let me know! I'm usually game, especially if it's a weekday evening or something? Weekends are tough sometimes but I'll be sure to try and make it!
Drink1975
QUOTE (littledutchboy @ Jun 13 2009, 07:39 PM)
You jerks get my opinions for free others pay dearly.

I'm wouldn't give you a cent for that opinion of me.
Nativeson
QUOTE (Livin-in-Lancaster @ Jun 15 2009, 09:28 AM)
My understanding is the school bus drivers with First Student are contract employees not school district employees and that they need to bid for contracts with school districts. If they put in a bid that is too high, the school district picks another bus company and First Student drivers are all out of work.

It will be interesting to see what happens.


Your understanding is exactly right. I am also very interested to see what happens next year when another bus contractor is picking up the First Student kids. Maybe they could go on strike and make the school district hire them back... or maybe they could spend their new-found free time going around to the home owners in that school district and explain to them why it is they should be paying even more property tax.
fullthrottlefan
QUOTE (Right of Smart @ Jun 15 2009, 12:28 PM)
The hardworking, risk takers, and intelligent still have a chance to benefit under this system.

GOP 2009: Rich people just can't get a break !

lol...
mnepats52
Unionizing part-time workers!! What a laugh!!
Seems they were only looking at the dollars signs being dangled infront of their faces and were not looking at the big picture.
In the long run this move will only do two things. Line the pockets of the union bosses and drive up costs on the bus company.
Which will only in turn be passed on to the district who will pass it on to the taxpayer.
Add a union and everyone loses!
Robotspyder
Top Ads