Current Conditions
42°F - CLEAR
A weighty issue: Motorcycles in left-turn lanes
Final report: Column 76 percent successful
Lancaster New Era
Jun 25, 2009 10:28 EST
LANCASTER
By Joe Hainthaler, Staff Writer
What is the minimum vehicle weight needed to trigger the left-turn signals at intersections with sensors under the pavement? And should those sensors be made more sensitive as more commuters turn to scooters, mopeds and bicycles to reduce gasoline consumption?
Media Center

Related Topics

Related Stories

Bookmark and Share

I drive a lightweight, 50-cc motorscooter (about 250 pounds, plus rider) that is fully licensed and road-legal. But it doesn't seem to be heavy enough for some road sensors to recognize. At least twice I have sat through light cycles, with a lineup of vehicles behind me, because my scooter couldn't trigger the left-turn arrow.

This has happened at Golden Triangle and at the Harrisburg Pike/President Avenue/Dillerville Road intersection. These intersections are dangerous enough, without having to make an unsafe maneuver after getting stuck at a light.

—GARDEN SPOT GAS MISER
Believe it or not, your motorscooter does not have a weight problem.

It's a lack of metal that's causing those traffic signals to ignore you.

Here's how Pennsylvania Department of Transportation spokeswoman Fritzi Schreffler explained things in an e-mail interview this week.

When a car — or a motorcycle with sufficient metal in it — enters those left-turn lanes, a magnetic-loop sensor is tripped, activating the left-turn signal and keeping the light red for oncoming traffic.

PennDOT's recommended strategy for folks on motorcycles and the like: Keep to the left portion of the lane, which gives you a better chance of being detected by the sensors. Those sensors are shaped like hexagons, so pulling a narrow vehicle into the middle of a sensor-equipped lane increases your chances of being ignored.

What's our metal-light scooter rider to do?

Carefully exploit an exception to the state's no-turn-left-on-a-red-arrow rule. If you wait through one full light cycle to be sure the loop is ignoring you and then proceed when it's safe to do so, you're acting legally, according to then-state House Transportation Committee Chairman Rick Geist, who offered the opinion during a June 2006 hearing.

Just be prepared to explain to a police officer that the motor vehicle code allows a driver to treat a left-turn signal like a stop sign when a traffic signal malfunctions.

You could also start rooting for House Bill 590, which would add a more specific exception to the state vehicle code: If, while on a bicycle, motorcycle or motorscooter, you've waited through a light cycle and been ignored by the magnetic loop, the bill would allow you to "proceed with due caution when it is safe to do so."

Charles Umbenhauer, the lobbyist for the motorcyclists' group ABATE of Pennsylvania, said the bill is needed because many police officers don't know about the exception, and the publicity surrounding the passage of a new and more explicit law would help motorcyclists and bicycle riders. The bill has been slowed down by controversial additions, including an amendment concerning the tolling of Interstate 80, he said.

But, Umbenhauer says, "We're going to keep working at it. We're going to keep pushing, and hopefully we can get it accomplished this session."

And, finally, you can encourage municipal officials — who are in charge of traffic signals, even those on state roads — to switch to video-detection sytems.

The half-million-dollar new traffic signals at the intersection of Route 322 and Railroad Avenue and Wanner Road in Earl Township includes cameras, which do not discriminate by weight or metal.

And a stretch of Route 30 — between Route 896 and Oakview Road — is to get them courtesy of a developer, according to Ralph Hutchison, the manager in East Lampeter Township.

The video monitors should help people on bicycles, on motorcyles and in buggies, and help the township reduce its costs, Hutchison said. Magnetic loops are expensive to repair when they malfunction, he said.

***

The van reported abandoned June 9 near the former Stehli Silk Mill on Marshall Avenue was towed away Tuesday.

Manheim Township police have cited and fined the owner $500, plus other costs, department spokesman Sgt. Tom Rudzinski said Wednesday.

The towing will cost the township nothing, Rudzinski said, because an state-authorized salvor took it away. The salvage business must now follow state rules regarding what to charge the owner for the vehicle's return and, if the owner fails to claim the vehicle within a timeframe set in state law, the salvor gets to keep it, Rudzinski said.

***

The leaning cupola on Buchanan Park's replica county courthouse that faces Race Avenue should be straightened "within a week or so," David Shaffhauser, facilities manager with Lancaster City Parks and Recreation, told Lancaster County Lookout on Wednesday.

Shaffhauser inspected the cupola recently and, finding it in "pretty bad shape," has decided to have a city carpenter fix its support structure — a temporary fix that should last for years.

Long term, he said he hopes to remove the cupola, repair its wood and tin flashing and replace it.

And Shaffauser is still hoping to get in touch with students at Thaddeus Stevens College of Technology, or some other organization interested in a community service project, to do some major repairs on the courthouse's windows and roof. During World War I, bonds were sold out of the replica Lancaster County Courthouse, which stood on Penn Square before making its move to Buchanan Park.

"We're going to try to repair it and redo it, so it's got another hundred years," Shaffhauser said.

***

You have just read Lancaster County Lookout's final report.

The Lookout wants to thank the many readers who took the time to observe and report community problems across Lancaster County over the past 71 weeks.

Your efforts have been largely successful. Of 85 fixable problems addressed in this column, 53 have been fixed and 12 more at least partially fixed for a success rate of 76 percent overall.

A special tip of the cap goes to officials in Lancaster City, where 85 percent of the 27 problems reported in this space were corrected.

Best wishes to all.

Recent Posts
Showing 5 most recent comments out of 37 total TalkBack comments about this article
View full comments | Comment on this article
QUOTE (BigBaron55 @ Jun 30 2009, 06:32 AM)
Such a dangerous travel method, so dangerous....its scary

It can be scary to some people, I get that. But it doesn't have to be as dangerous as some people make it. It can actually be good for society: motorcycles and scooters use less resources and less space to transport a person than a car or an SUV. You don't need a Ford Excursion to transport one person to work every day. Part of the danger of motorbikes in America is that most car drivers are casual about their driving, and often only look out for other car-sized and car-shaped objects. If more people rode motorbikes, traffic would decrease, less space would need to be paved for parking, America would use less gas, and we riders would be safer due to increased awareness.

Plus, it's a lot of fun. When was the last time you enjoyed your commute? Felt the cool air as you crossed a bridge. Smelled the bakery as you passed it? Sometimes the time between home and job is the only time one spends outside... why choose to spend it in a stale, climate-controlled bubble?
greidel
QUOTE (solitary @ Jun 26 2009, 03:35 PM)
his point is "I'm a cager! it's not fair!".
He doesn't understand that you can wait at a light that's not sensitive enough until a car comes up behind you, and that could be a long, long time. Some busy intersections I've waited five minutes until I got a car behind me. By that time, my passenger had re-mounted the bike from pressing the cross-walk button.

I did, twice.
Running a light: $160? total fine and five points. (assuming it doesn't qualify under the malfunctioning light statute of the law.)
Using an unauthorized EMS light changer after 2002? The good news is there's no points, the bad news is, you won't be able to use your driver's license for a long, long time. On top of that, the fine is insane.
Yes, you can buy them, legally. No, I won't tell you where.


QUOTE
his point is "I'm a cager! it's not fair!".
He doesn't understand that you can wait at a light that's not sensitive enough until a car comes up behind you, and that could be a long, long time.


Jack is not known by you.

I have been a non-cager for over 45 years. Current life-member HOG (Harley Owners Group), currently own and ride a 2003 (100th anniversary) Heritage Custom, which has just over 36,000 miles on it, and a 1984 Honda V65 Magnum.

I fully understand what it is to have to wait for a trigger (although my Harley works more often than not) a light or a parking garage "arm".

There was no point it was pure sarcasm - like so many things - lost in the translation.

My bad.
grieker
QUOTE (greidel @ Jun 30 2009, 12:18 PM)
It can be scary to some people, I get that. But it doesn't have to be as dangerous as some people make it. It can actually be good for society: motorcycles and scooters use less resources and less space to transport a person than a car or an SUV. You don't need a Ford Excursion to transport one person to work every day. Part of the danger of motorbikes in America is that most car drivers are casual about their driving, and often only look out for other car-sized and car-shaped objects. If more people rode motorbikes, traffic would decrease, less space would need to be paved for parking, America would use less gas, and we riders would be safer due to increased awareness.

Plus, it's a lot of fun. When was the last time you enjoyed your commute? Felt the cool air as you crossed a bridge. Smelled the bakery as you passed it? Sometimes the time between home and job is the only time one spends outside... why choose to spend it in a stale, climate-controlled bubble?


Exactly.

It makes little sense to me, as a conservative, to ride around in a vehicle that conserves little. Even my personal car is relatively small, conserving both space and fuel, though it's not even currently registered since it never gets used.

Certainly, there are things I miss out on when riding my scooter, like the radio, air conditioning, and heat (during the winter) but there are so many other things that I get to enjoy, like the fresh air, the feel of the wind, the smells of nature, the taste of bugs...well, maybe not so much on the last one.

The only thing I fear while riding are the morons who aren't paying attention to what they are doing. So far, none of them have hit me, but they keep trying.
Rural Conservative
Well, it's become obvious to me that my Suzuki Bergman 650 scooter does not have enough weight to trip the ground sensor....I've now taken to adding an errand that takes me to the right at the light on 72 in front of the Renfaire...even rolling back & forth I can't trigger the light!!!

Know what ya mean about bugs, too....yuk!!!
Susan
starfleet2
QUOTE (starfleet2 @ Jul 2 2009, 08:42 PM)
Well, it's become obvious to me that my Suzuki Bergman 650 scooter does not have enough weight to trip the ground sensor....I've now taken to adding an errand that takes me to the right at the light on 72 in front of the Renfaire...even rolling back & forth I can't trigger the light!!!

Know what ya mean about bugs, too....yuk!!!
Susan

IT'S NOT THE WEIGHT - these aren't scales.

It is the ferrous mass of the vehicle.
grieker
Top Ads