Current Conditions
42°F - CLEAR
Donegal trims building plan
Intelligencer Journal
Lancaster New Era
Jul 03, 2009 10:02 EST
Mount Joy
By DEAN LEE EVANS, Correspondent

Media Center

Related Topics

Related Stories

Bookmark and Share
A failed referendum, taxpayer backlash and public surveys led Donegal School District officials to scale back a proposed building plan scheduled for a referendum in November.

The revised plan discussed by officials June 25 proposes the construction of a high school, while leaving all other buildings without renovations for the immediate future.

Officials are expected to adopt wording of the new referendum Sept. 8 and develop a floor plan for the public to view.

The initial referendum's price tag of $114 million included a new high school estimated to cost $55.6 million. It also proposed a new school to replace Maytown Elementary, a central receiving department building, major renovations to nearly every other school building and new and improved athletic facilities.

During the June 25 meeting, district business manager Amy Swartz suggested changes to trim the cost of the high school project to $52.3 million.

The district could save $3.3 million by eliminating a field house, indoor running track, auditorium balcony and 100 parking spaces; combining a wrestling room with an auxiliary gym; and reducing a four-wing school to two wings.

But even that price tag left some board members wondering if the project has a chance to attract taxpayer support in November.

Board member Patrick Mitchell said, "After the defeat last time, which wasn't even close, I'm concerned that despite all the hard work and lowering the numbers down to $50 million for a new high school, that we still won't have enough residents to vote for it."

Mitchell said earlier in the meeting that if the referendum fails, building needs in Donegal would have to be addressed under existing budget revenues and a state-mandated tax index, which is tailored to each school district by the Department of Education. "I hope I'm wrong about the referendum, but I'm sorry, I just don't see it happening," he said. "If we keep painting ourselves in a corner, we're going to end up with a problem with a growing population and not enough income to cover these kids."

District officials opted for a new high school due to the age and inadequate infrastructure in the current high school.

Superintendent Shelly Riedel said, "We are going to be positive and go into this fall referendum with some positive messages." She said the school has had a shortage of classroom space since 1976, when the district began adding modular units in the rear parking lot. Modular units were added from 1976 to 1990 and 1993 to the present.

She said the district replaced several of the large modular units in 2003, and a double unit set up in 2007 brought the number of classrooms to 14. In addition, four modular classrooms installed starting in 2001 are in use at the middle school. Riedel said the district purchased most of the modular units at Donegal knowing they were constructed to last eight to 10 years.

John Boughter, director of maintenance, said the aging modular units are showing wear and tear.

In April, John Coleman, a board member and facility chairman, said roof repairs on the modular units could cost $250,000.

If voters approve a new high school, grade realignment would help alleviate classroom space needs in other buildings.

Riedel said the student population at Donegal has been increasing over the years, and the trend is expected to continue because of residential development in East Donegal Township and Mount Joy Borough.

"We are already up over 200 kindergarten registrations for next year," she said. "In prior times, we have the potential to get 20 to 30 more children, which is not the best situation. Kindergarten is always our biggest unknown."

Board president Steven Cafrelli said, "When this economy picks up again, (housing construction) will take off again."


Recent Posts
TalkBack comments about this article
Comment on this article
QUOTE (Lancaster Online @ Jul 3 2009, 10:02 AM)
Post your thoughts and comments about this article.


I knew it. It really has nothign to do with the amount. Any amount proposed will not be passed as long as the number of retirees outnumbers the parents at the polls.

Later...Shawn
Shawn
When the referendum was defeated before, many voters said they would approve it if it was cut in half. Now the district has cut it in half + and they are worried it still won't pass??? What will happen to Maytown in 3-5 years when they are faced with probably having to close it. If the current high school doesn't get any renovations, how is it appropriate to put 7th and 8th grade there (which is the plan)? The lack of vision in this community is very disheartening!
musichollie
"John Coleman, a board member and facility chairman, said roof repairs on the modular units could cost $250,000"

Who are they hiring to do the roof!!! Must be using a government contractor!!!

My son was getting his done, including new wood for $3,800.00
TheHunter
QUOTE (TheHunter @ Jul 4 2009, 09:52 AM)
"John Coleman, a board member and facility chairman, said roof repairs on the modular units could cost $250,000"

Who are they hiring to do the roof!!! Must be using a government contractor!!!

My son was getting his done, including new wood for $3,800.00


Here's the difference- house roof vs. commercial school roof, and there are 18+ modular units in Donegal. That's why they are so expensive. You need certain contractors, certain materials, etc.
musichollie
Top Ads