Current Conditions
36°F - SUNNY
Columbia council, mayor support regionalization of fire companies, police departments
Intelligencer Journal
Lancaster New Era
Oct 14, 2009 09:26 EST
Columbia
By JAMES BUESCHER, Correspondent

Efforts to merge the three fire companies in Columbia Borough and regionalize the borough's fire crews and police department with rescue and law enforcement organizations in neighboring municipalities got a boost at Monday's council meeting.

Before the end of the month, council agreed to send letters to leaders of fire companies in Marietta, Wrightsville and Mountville. The letters will ask to neighboring officials to respond by Dec. 18.

Council did not set a timeline for contacting area police departments, instead asking Columbia Mayor Leo Lutz to send out letters.

"We are a at a critical point with our volunteer fire departments. A lot of the communities around us are joining together and regionalizing their services, and, unless we get on the bus, we're going to be left behind," Mary Barninger, a councilwoman, said Monday.

If Columbia doesn't start to act now, she said, "we'll be left as an island. We need to take steps while we can before any chance at regionalization passes us by," she said.

Sandy Duncan, council president, said Tuesday the borough has been discussing the idea of consolidating its three fire companies — Columbia No. 1 Fire Company, Susquehanna Fire & Rescue Company No. 4 and Columbia Consolidated Fire Company — since 2008.

Earlier this month, she said Rob Brady, a representative of the state's Department of Community and Economic Development, spoke to council's safety committee about the proposed consolidation. She said Brady suggested the idea of regionalizing the fire companies with departments in nearby communities.

At least one resident, however, raised objections to the idea of joining with other fire departments.

Herbert "Cubby" Spiese of Columbia said, "What's good for a place like Washington Boro might not be good for Columbia. We don't seem to be gaining much by doing this."

Resident Shirley McBride said that looking into regionalization "can't hurt. It used to be that employers encouraged firefighters. Employees got paid to leave to go and fight a bad fire, and even the ladies went out to get food for the men. Now, those days are long gone," she said.

"Today, fire companies are struggling for funding and volunteers. … I think we should at least look into this. Nothing ventured, nothing gained," she said.

After council voted to begin contacting regional fire companies, Lutz brought up the idea of doing the same thing with area police departments.

He said, "In this economic climate, we have to look at doing things cheaper. Costs are skyrocketing, and the money is just not there anymore."

The issue of joining forces with nearby police departments, Lutz said, "may not go anywhere. But at least we can say we tried," he said. "We won't know where it goes until we sit down and talk about it."


Recent Posts
TalkBack comments about this article
Comment on this article
Regionalization is a great for cost and services, however it must be done with Geography and Municipal lines in mind.

Wrightsville is not in Lancaster county and does use the same 911 system, regardless of location, this doesn't make sense.

Columbia police should join forces with West Hempfield and whoever covers Washington Boro.

Fire department - Columbia has always had too many stations and not enough volunteers. Marietta and Columbia does not make sense due to Chickies Hill, a strong physical barrier to rapid response. Columbia, Mountville and Washington Boro make alot of sense. Marrietta, Bainbridge and Maytown makes sense if they can get out of the way of their own egos. Elizabethown, Rheems and Mt. Joy make sense.

Consolidation is good, it reduces duplication and increases the professional level of service the community receives.

Kudos to Columbia for taking the first step.

subvet68
I agree with your analysis but I think you meant to say Wrightsville does not use the same 911 system...
WGM1171
didn't columbia police look into merging with West Hempfield once before and that went nowhere?

is it me or has the MT/LT deal set off a firestorm of merger talks lately? Mountville/West Hempfield, Columbia and whoever....Do I hear a Lititz/Warwick out there? Maybe an Etown/Mt Joy/NW Regional?
afsoc1981
Marietta? Mountville? What do you gain by adding them into the discussion??

Columbia currently has a "self-sufficient" system of fire protection. Many departments currently find it standard practice to have 3 Engines, 2 Ladder Trucks and 1 Rescue on an initial alarm of a fire. Columbia Borough has within its limits, 3 Engines, 2 Ladder Trucks and 1 Rescue. One overarching body to govern the three organizations is needed, yes. But if you are talking about shutting down fire stations and liquidating apparatus, go climb a tree and hope the lawyers don't find you. If you think for one minute that a fire comes in two houses down from the fire station you just shut down and someone dies that you won't be sued? There's a probable chance that because the personnel and equipment are so close there is a very good chance that 1, the fire could be contained faster, 2 th rescue attempts could have begun sooner and 3 that less property damage would be sustained. If you shut down a fire station that is 1 mile away from another, there is a pretty good chance that you didn't do anything but hurt the situation. You may have just cut your expenses a little, but was you really lose are the volunteers. Volunteers don't come back once they're gone. Proven FACT! There are many people in this county that are alive today solely because of the fact that the volunteer fire station was only blocks away and if they would have had to wait for help from farther away, they would be dead. End of discussion.
Morbid
Top Ads